A Prelude to Bread Loaf:
1937 - 1939
THE STRENGTH OF THE HILLS
IS HIS ALSO.
- On September 18, 1938, toward early
sunset, I stood before the Middlebury College Mead Memorial Chapel
and read this Biblical inscription (Psalms, 95: 4) chiseled in
marble across the facade of its portico. The chapel, a Greek
classical structure with six marble columns across the portico,
was topped by a white New England meeting house steeple reaching
toward heaven. In its Biblical emblem, mixed architecture, and
Vermont setting, the chapel embodied perfectly the Congregational
Calvinist origins of Middlebury College in 1800, as evolved into
a modern, rural, New England liberal arts college.
The chapel faced toward the east and was silhouetted on the rim
of a long sloping hill overlooking the gray-granite, ivy-covered
buildings of "Old Stone Row" on the lower campus. Beyond
these buildings, farther downhill, lay the village of Middlebury
, shire town of Addison County, largely hidden under green summer
foliage, but flecked here and there by the first faint gold of
approaching Indian summer. From the northeast the dark green
shadow of Chipman Hill covered the village. Five miles or so
farther east the low-lying Front range of the Green Mountains
rose three to four thousand feet above Champlain Valley , running
north and south to each horizon. At their rim against the sky
the dark, unevenly shadowed ranges were touched here and there
with a purple glow, a gold and maroon haze, from the sun fading
below the Adirondack Mountains twelve miles to the west, beyond
Lake Champlain. To the northeast, past the villages of Bristol
and Lincoln, Mount Ellen rose 4,135 feet above the valley. Six
miles to the southeast lay the tiny village of East Middlebury,
nestled against the foot of Ripton Gorge, along which ran state
highway 125, the road that wound its way four miles through the
first range of the Green Mountains to the village of Ripton.
Three miles or so beyond were the Bread Loaf Inn and the Middlebury
College mountain campus of the Bread Loaf School of English.
The cottages of the campus lay on both sides of the road, in
an open clearing of a large plateau surrounded by evergreen forests
and mountain ranges. Almost directly north was the most conspicuous
landmark from the campus, Bread Loaf Mountain, rising 3,823 feet
high.
Standing there before the chapel steps that September evening
I was almost totally unfamiliar with the geography of Vermont
and the history and character of Middlebury College. I had arrived
only the day before, hitchhiking up from New Jersey, to enter
Middlebury as a freshman in the class of 1942. I had come up
two days early, to find work so I could earn my way through college.
Since the events that had finally led me to Middlebury had great
bearing upon my college life, and eventually determined my going
to Bread Loaf for eight summers, it is necessary to review briefly
my earlier schooling and my literary experience before I met
Robert Frost.
In 1923, when I was three years old, my parents had moved out
of the "Ironbound" slums of Newark, New Jersey, where
I was born, to the beautiful rural suburb of Nutley. I grew up
in ideal surroundings and graduated from Nutley High School in
June 1937. But the United States was still in the great depression,
and my family had a very hard struggle to survive. Between June
1937 and September 1938 I spent months in fruitless searching
for work. After making the rounds of shops and factories each
morning, I usually spent my afternoons and evenings in the Nutley
Public Library. In fourteen months I read several hundreds of
books - much history, politics, and science, some philosophy,
but particularly the fine arts and literature.
I read voraciously yet selectively in the whole range of English
and American fiction, drama, and poetry. Since childhood I had
had an intense and natural affinity for poetry, graduating from
Mother Goose and Robert Louis Stevenson's A
Child's Garden of Verses to the poetry anthologies of Louis
Untermeyer used as texts in high school. I had soon discovered
that when I liked a poem, often a single reading enabled me to
retain it in memory and to quote it in full, almost regardless
of its length. Later, when I came to know Frost well, he said
my acute memory for poetry was the result of "out-of-school"
and "self-assigned" readings, rather than "in-
school" and "laid-on" education. However it may
be explained, I read poetry in the spirit of what Frost in "A
Tuft of Flowers" called "sheer morning gladness at
the brim" (p. 23 ). Undoubtedly, Frost was largely right.
The poems lodged in my mind because I read them with all the
intense and spontaneous enthusiasm of uncritical youth, with
an intuitional love, or what Frost called "passionate preference"
(Interviews, p. 208), and not as a body of academic knowledge
to be learned. During the fourteen months prior to entering Middlebury
I read and retained in memory thousands of lines of poetry, from
Shakespeare's sonnets, lyrics, and plays; from the poems of Ben
Jonson, Donne, Herrick, and the Cavalier poets; from Milton,
Dryden, Pope, Thompson, Gray, Blair, Young, Samuel Johnson and
Goldsmith; from all the major and some minor Romantic and Victorian
poets; and from the modern British and American poets in the
latest edition of Untermeyer's anthology, including Frost. Among
American nineteenth century poets I knew to memory many poems
of Bryant, Poe, Emerson, Whitman, Crane, Dickinson, and others.
Although I did not realize it then, I was really preparing myself
in the best possible manner for entering Middlebury, for my summers
at Bread Loaf, and for my conversations with Frost. But because
of the depressed economic condition of my family, and my inability
to find work, until Christmas of 1937 I had not entertained any
hope of going to college at all. Then by chance I met a history
teacher I had known in Nutley High School. About the middle of
December Miss Esther Byerley found me reading in the library,
and with the help of one of my high school English teachers,
Miss Ida Cone, who had sent several students to Middlebury College,
encouraged me to apply for admission. In February 1938 I was
admitted with a half tuition scholarship. Through odd jobs during
the spring and summer I managed to save fifty dollars, my total
financial resources when I journeyed to Middlebury on September
17 to look for work.
The next day I managed to find four meager jobs - as usher in
a theater downtown; as a page in the college library; as attendance
officer in daily and Sunday chapel; and as a campus mailman,
delivering mail and notices from the administration offices in
Old Chapel to the various faculty offices. All these jobs together
were not enough to cover my room, board, and books, and beyond
these expenses I still needed to raise half of my tuition. But
that evening, in front of the chapel, entranced by the magnificence
of the campus setting and distant mountains, I had pushed my
economic problems completely out of my mind, so that for a moment
I was hardly aware that a man had come out of the chapel and
was standing next to me.
He was tall, white-haired, and somewhat frail; he was well-dressed
and carried a black cane. He had the dignified, formal bearing
of a Victorian gentleman, and looked like the very image of a
picture I had seen of John Galsworthy. He smiled broadly, shook
my hand, asked my name and home town, and whether I was to be
a student at the College. Soon we were launched on an animated
conversation about the College and various academic subjects,
and particularly on the place of literature in a liberal education.
Newman's The Idea of a University, which I had read with
great satisfaction just before going to Middlebury, provided
the basis for my convictions. As we talked we strolled slowly
down the long walk from the chapel to the lower campus, where
for about a half hour we talked within the shadow of Old Chapel
as darkness descended. Then the white-haired gentleman suddenly
said goodbye and walked away. I was mortified to discover that
although he had probed my mind, I had neglected to ask anything
about him. I hadn't even gotten his name. I was acutely embarrassed
over my bad manners.
Early the next afternoon when I went to the college mail room
in Old Chapel to pick up campus mail for distribution, to my
surprise I found a note in my box asking me to go immediately
to the office of Dr. Paul D. Moody, President of Middlebury College.
I went upstairs and gave my name to his secretary. To my greater
surprise she recognized my name. She ushered me into the president's
office, and to my utter amazement there stood the white-haired
gentleman I had met outside the chapel. He smiled indulgently
at my obvious stupefaction. Dr. Moody quickly put me at ease
by assuring me that our conversation of the previous evening
had pleased him. He wished to continue
it and discuss some matters relating to my coming year at Middlebury.
In the next half hour I listened and learned a great deal about
President Moody. He was the son of the famous evangelist Dwight
L. Moody (1837-1899); he had been head Protestant chaplain in
the American Expeditionary Forces in France during World War
One; he had met such luminaries as Marshal Foch and Sergeant
York; he had known intimately and was a close friend of Father
Francis P. Duffy, the famous chaplain of the New York City regiments
of the Forty-second Rainbow Division; he had been appointed President
of Middlebury College in 1921; his daughter, Charlotte Moody,
had literary talents of the kind I admired, and had published
in The Saturday Review of Literature, Harpers, and various
magazines of fiction. By an easy transition from things personal
to him to things literary , President Moody steered his monologue
to the main purpose of our meeting. From fragments in our recent
conversation he had pieced together the facts about my economic
plight. He told me that out of his "President's Purse,"
a fund provided by the College for use at his discretion, he
would pay the balance of my tuition for my freshman year. Before
I had recovered sufficiently to thank him for this startling
generosity, President Moody told me he had also asked the registrar
to schedule me in the freshman English class to be taught by
Professor Harry G. Owen. With that, President Moody shook my
hand warmly, wished me well, asked me to drop in occasionally
for a chat during the coming months, and ushered me out.
On the same day that classes began at Middlebury , September
21, 1938, a devastating hurricane swept across the northeastern
United States, killing nearly 700 people, and damaging property
worth tens of millions of dollars. Near Middlebury the hurricane
washed out highways and bridges, stranding some parents of students
for days. Symbolically, this regional catastrophe, and the resulting
physical damage and dislocation of human lives, was but a prelude
to what the whole civilized world was soon to experience in World
War Two. On our first day of classes Czechoslovakia capitulated
to Hitler's partition ultimatum. Four years later almost to the
day, I was to be inducted into the United States Air Corps at
Fort Dix. Meanwhile, against the background of the politics and
violence of approaching war, I plunged
into the calm but intellectually exhilarating academic world
of Middlebury and the Bread Loaf School of English, a highly
civilized, aesthetically oriented, and idealistic world, peopled
with scores of outstanding teachers, scholars, poets, writers,
fellow students, and a variety of remarkable characters.
Soon after classes began I discovered why President Moody had
steered me into Professor Owen's English class. Owen was a brilliant
and highly articulate teacher, thoroughly educated in the fine
arts as well as in literature. He had a catholic literary taste
that included an appreciation of the best in Ancient, Classical,
Metaphysical, Romantic, and Modern literature. He was intensely
devoted to music and was a very accomplished pianist. Freshman
English at Middlebury consisted of a year-long survey course
in English literature, with reading selections from Beowulf through
Thomas Hardy, in two large volumes. But Owen demanded much more
than the rest of his colleagues. He assigned supplementary readings:
a Shakespearean tragedy, comedy, and history; an eighteenth and
nineteenth century novel; Boswell's Life of Samuel Johnson;
and selected essays in literary criticism. He also required two
or three brief themes each week, written on the daily assigned
readings. By June 1939 I had written over forty critical papers
for Owen, thus deepening, extending, consolidating, and systematizing
my knowledge and understanding of English literature. Owen was
a strict disciplinarian, and held frequent conferences with his
students to improve their writing. Although I had entered Middlebury
as a physics major, I soon shifted to English because I was more
interested in people than in atoms and molecules, and Owen became
my academic advisor. Before going to Middlebury I had become
interested in writing, both poetry and prose. I had composed
about twenty lyric poems, mostly sonnets, and had written some
reflective essays. Owen provided great critical perspective for
my work.
Before Christmas recess, largely through Owen's teaching and
conferences, but also through the example of two other faculty
members at Middlebury, Professors Vernon G. Harrington in philosophy
and Reginald L. Cook in American Literature, I had decided that
for my life's work I wanted to teach literature in a college
and to write. But the whole course of my graduate studies in
literature, and of my professional life, was to be determined
by Robert Frost.
In addition to his teaching skill, Owen possessed great social
charm and tact and was an outstanding administrator. In 1937
President Moody had appointed him Dean of the Bread Loaf School
of English. (Several years later, after Owen became academic
dean at Rutgers University, I learned from Frost that President
Moody had groomed Owen to succeed him as president of Middlebury
College, but that the War had destroyed this plan.) In January
1939, Owen offered me a scholarship and all expenses to attend
the Bread Loaf School for the coming summer, in exchange for
waiting on table. He reminded me that to teach in a college I
would need M.A. and Ph.D. degrees and that going to Bread Loaf
was the first step toward these academic goals. Owen agreed with
the philosophy of education then practiced under Robert M. Hutchins
at the University of Chicago, that a student should be allowed
to proceed according to his proven ability and attained knowledge
and skill, rather than through a piecemeal system of fixed earned
credits. If I could handle the graduate courses at Bread Loaf,
Owen argued, I should be able to earn credits toward an M.A.
even before getting the B.A. He also noted that at Bread Loaf
I would have an opportunity to study with outstanding English
teachers from all over the United States, under ideal conditions,
and that this would make me a stronger undergraduate English
student. His clinching point was that I would meet Robert Frost
at Bread Loaf and that after the summer school session I could
stay over for the last two weeks in August and attend the Bread
Loaf Writers' Conference.
But the hard-pressing facts of economics stood in the way of
accepting Owen's very tempting offer. I believed it was essential
to earn money over the summer for my sophomore year and to secure
the B.A. before being concerned about advanced degrees. I discussed
my problem with "Gramps" Harrington. He had taught
for thirteen summers at Bread Loaf, from 1920, the year the school
was founded, through 1932. He knew Frost well and had a very
high opinion of the poet. He advised me to take the long range
view, to ignore economics, live on faith, and go to Bread Loaf.
I then consulted "Doc" Cook, whom I had come to admire
as a man and a teacher. Cook had taken his M.A. at Bread Loaf
in 1926, and he too was a good friend of Frost. He urged me to
go to Bread Loaf, saying that the opportunity to know Frost was
the greatest education in the liberal arts I could possibly get
anywhere. President Moody reinforced the advice of Harrington
and Cook and assured me that my full tuition scholarship would
be extended as long as my academic record was good. He suggested
that I apply to the Middlebury Inn for a job during my sophomore
year; I did and secured a job that gave me room and board starting
in September. I then accepted Owen's offer.
"Robert Frost at Bread Loaf, 1939"
Part I
- In Part I, a youthful
Peter Stanlis and his classmates meet Frost
- for the first time in
a little cottage in Ripton.
"All the way home I kept remembering"